Workforce Development in Higher Education: Apprenticeships, Industry Partnerships and Stackable Credentials:

Changing Higher Ed podcast 335 with host Dr. Drumm McNaughton and guest Chuck Johnson

Table of Contents

Changing Higher Ed podcast 335 with Dr. Drumm McNaughton and Chuck Johnson | Workforce Development in Higher Education: Apprenticeships, Industry Partnerships and Stackable Credentials

October 27, 2026 · Episode 335

Workforce U: How Vincennes University Built a Nationwide Apprenticeship Model With Amazon

37 Min · By Dr. Drumm McNaughton

How Vincennes University built a nationwide apprenticeship model with Amazon: President Chuck Johnson on workforce development in higher education.

Probably in May 2019, as Chuck Johnson recalls it, Amazon came back to Vincennes University with a bigger request than the training it had first discussed: a four-year registered apprenticeship, to start when a new Indianapolis fulfillment center opened at the end of September. Johnson, the university’s president, was picturing early 2020. Amazon’s answer, he says, was, “You don’t understand. We deliver things overnight.” The program launched that September with 44 associates, and 43 of them eventually completed it.

Johnson describes Indiana as facing a “double whammy”: a shrinking high school cohort, and a smaller share of graduates going straight to college, a rate he calls hard to raise given concerns about the ROI of college. His response has been to build programs that need not lead an 18-year-old directly into a baccalaureate: stackable and workforce-aligned credentials, work-based learning and apprenticeships, built with employers as partners. For presidents and boards facing the same demographics, the question is what an institution is willing to count as success.

In this episode of the Changing Higher Ed® podcast, Dr. Drumm McNaughton speaks with Dr. Chuck Johnson, President of Vincennes University. Johnson came to VU as provost in 2012, after roles at Bowling Green State University, in banking and at Purdue University’s Krannert School of Management, and has led the university since 2015. The conversation covers what workforce development in higher education looks like at an institution that has leaned into it. Topics include the Amazon partnership and Workforce U, industry advisory councils, annual program metrics, a faculty model built for flexibility and a teacher apprenticeship pilot.

Quick Overview

  • Vincennes University was founded in 1801, before Indiana was a state; Johnson says it became a junior college in 1889, about 12 years before Joliet Junior College, which is often cited as the first
  • Johnson says VU has graduated some 1,200 apprentices from across North America since 2020 in a residential training program of about 12 weeks that it runs for Amazon on its campus
  • Walmart piloted programs last fall and brought its program to full steam this year, Johnson says, making Amazon and Walmart VU’s two anchor partners
  • VU has rebranded its business and industry arm as Workforce U, a trademarked name, to signal training built around employers’ talent needs
  • About 35 industry advisory councils give VU regular feedback from alumni and employers, Johnson says
  • Johnson says an annual program metrics report calculates each program’s cost per graduate, alongside a formal program review about every five years
  • John Deere donates close to $1 million of equipment each year, Johnson says, which keeps a costly program viable
  • Johnson says VU’s board caps tenure and tenure-track positions at 50% of faculty in any program, department or school
  • A teacher apprenticeship pilot with about half a dozen schools lets associate degree holders work as paraprofessionals while finishing a bachelor’s degree online
  • VU is committing about $20 million to renovate a residence hall for adult learners and its workforce programs

Indiana’s Enrollment Cliff Is a Double Whammy

McNaughton frames the market with a figure from his earlier conversation with Johnson: the share going on to college has fallen from 65% to 51%, with more young people going straight into the workforce or not going to college at all. Johnson describes Indiana’s version of the enrollment cliff as two declines at once. The high school cohort is shrinking, and so is the rate at which high school graduates go on to college.

In principle, Johnson says, an institution could offset the population decline by raising the share of students who go on directly to college. In practice he calls that “a heavy lift right now given the questions and the concerns around the ROI of college.” VU, he says, has tried to position itself with programming that may not lead directly to a baccalaureate degree at 18.

He also points to VU’s culture. “We have a history of being a scrappy institution,” Johnson says. “We find ways to get the job done even if it’s not the way we’ve always done it.” While VU’s traditional numbers have suffered, he says, the numbers in its workforce programs have continued to grow.

For boards, the enrollment cliff becomes a question of which students, and which outcomes, the institution is built to serve.

A Junior College With Baccalaureate Pathways

Johnson calls VU a unique institution. It is the oldest college in Indiana, founded in 1801 when Vincennes was the territorial capital, and its founder was territorial governor William Henry Harrison, later President of the United States. It emerged as a two-year junior college in 1889, which Johnson says predates Joliet Junior College, often cited as the first junior college, by about 12 years.

In the 1960s, with no community college system in Indiana, VU was the state’s only junior college, he says, and it built residence halls to draw students from all 92 counties. In the late 1990s the state put VU together with Ivy Tech, then primarily a career and technical education school, in a merger meant to create a statewide community college system. Johnson recalls a rocky start; about four or five years later the two were split. Ivy Tech became the Community College of Indiana with transfer programs it had not had before, and VU picked up about seven baccalaureate programs.

Today, he says, the vast majority of the credentials VU awards are associate degrees, alongside growing baccalaureate pathways and certificate programs aligned with industry and workforce needs. McNaughton sums up the difference: VU is not a traditional university offering workforce development but “a junior college workforce development that offers baccalaureate degrees,” which he calls a difference of mentality. Johnson agrees, and adds that one challenge has been reminding VU that it offers more than associate degrees.

Several of those pathways are built for working adults: an RN to BSN that runs fully online, an LPN to BSN and a technology baccalaureate whose online courses are moving to eight weeks to suit adult learners. VU also offers a bachelor’s degree in homeland security, and Johnson says many of its graduates come out of VU’s military education sites. The history matters because it explains why VU already had residence halls, technical programs and employer relationships to offer when Amazon arrived.

“We Deliver Things Overnight”: How the Amazon Apprenticeship Began

Johnson calls the Amazon case a unique one. VU has long had a business and industry arm that works with employers on specific workforce needs, most of it non-credit, such as short courses and upskill training built on VU’s academic and apprenticeship programs. Amazon in particular came to VU in 2019, he recalls. The person leading Amazon’s new mechanization, robotics and automation group lived in central Indiana and visited VU’s logistics training center just outside the Indianapolis airport. Amazon was looking for a way to upskill the technical people who keep its fulfillment center systems running, starting with a new center on the south side of Indianapolis.

About six weeks later, Amazon asked for a four-year apprenticeship registered with the Department of Labor, aligned to credentials and certifications, to start when that center opened at the end of September. “We had no apprentices. They had no apprentices. We had no equipment,” Johnson says. VU also had no faculty lined up, no curriculum and no certifications. It launched the program in September 2019 anyway, with 44 associates; 43 of them completed it a couple of years later.

The lesson for presidents is about pace: the partner set the timeline, and the institution adjusted to it rather than the reverse.

From One Fulfillment Center to a Nationwide Residential Model

VU then invited the people leading Amazon’s program to its Vincennes campus. Johnson says the university pitched what it already had: a residential campus with the faculty, equipment and facilities to run the training at a broader scale. In late 2019 Amazon came back asking to pilot a nationwide apprenticeship model with VU, an intensive training program of about 12 weeks on campus with apprentices living in the residence halls. Planned for March 2020, it was delayed by COVID and began in May 2020.

Since then, Johnson says, VU has graduated some 1,200 apprentices from across North America through that initial training program. VU developed the credentialing and testing protocol with Amazon and runs all testing in its own center. Apprentices get housing, meals and the amenities any student would have. He calls it a turnkey operation, and says VU was the first school in the country to work with Amazon on its nationwide apprenticeship in mechatronics and automation.

Walmart came on last fall, piloted a couple of programs and brought its program up to full steam this year, making Amazon and Walmart VU’s two anchor partners. To support the model, Johnson says, VU is investing about $20 million to renovate one of its residence halls. And it has rebranded its business and industry area as Workforce U, a trademarked name meant to signal “something that works with you on developing the talent you need” rather than a traditional college experience.

For institutions with residential campuses, the model suggests that housing and student services can be part of what a workforce partner is looking for.

Workforce Development in Higher Education Means Counting More Than Degrees

Johnson says VU also chose not to fixate on academic credentials as the only goal. VU looked at industry credentials and certifications with value in the marketplace and tried to make them stackable into the next level of education. “If someone came to us and got four industry certifications, they’re more employable,” he says. That counted as a win “even if it didn’t show up in our traditional count of degree production.”

The same thinking shapes how VU reports its size. Enrollment on the Vincennes campus has held at about 2,300 to 2,400 students for the last three or four years, Johnson says, while system-wide headcount was about 20,000 last fall. Neither figure includes the Amazon, Walmart and other workforce learners. Because they do not show up in VU’s traditional enrollment numbers, or in what the state counts as degree completion, VU’s strategic plan includes working out how to account for them.

Early college is part of the same portfolio. VU runs early college programs around the state in career and technical pathways, where students get practical coursework, aligned to workforce needs in their communities, that stacks into a VU credential. “We can’t wait for people to come to us,” Johnson says.

For boards, a dashboard built only on degrees will undercount an institution doing workforce development well, which is why strategic planning and measurement need to change together.

Advisory Councils and a Board That Bring Industry to the Table

For an institution without VU’s profile, Johnson’s first advice is to get close to the industry sectors it already has a history with and has produced graduates for. VU has probably 35 industry advisory councils, he says, which meet regularly to gather feedback from alumni and employer partners on what is working, what is changing and what is on the horizon. Johnson also has advisory councils at his own level for the markets VU serves, and VU sits on industry councils at the state level and some at the national level.

McNaughton calls advisory councils something most institutions don’t do, and notes that employers will start sending their employees to an institution that is responsive enough. Johnson agrees, and adds that part of the purpose is to position VU for what it may need to offer in three or four years. AI, he says, is “a huge question mark” for teaching and for industry, and “we’ve gotta be in those conversations as early as possible.” See also the podcast’s episode on employer engagement in higher education.

Johnson describes his board as another such council. Its members come from sectors VU serves, including healthcare, advanced manufacturing, energy and agriculture, and they bring connections and news from their industries and communities. They are supportive, he says, but “they don’t come in with their own agendas.” McNaughton’s shorthand for that posture is NIFO: “nose in, fingers out.” Drawing trustees from the sectors an institution serves is a board governance choice that can be made deliberately.

The state is a partner too. Johnson says the IEDC, Indiana’s economic development agency, brings VU into conversations early when the agency is trying to attract new industry. That helps VU see what is coming and helps prospective employers understand what Indiana’s institutions can do.

Annual Program Metrics Between Five-Year Reviews

McNaughton raises a point from their earlier conversation: VU reviews its programs every year to manage staffing and cost. Johnson describes an annual program metrics report covering enrollment, degree production, other credential production and the cost of instruction, whether personnel, capital or equipment. From those, VU calculates a cost factor: whether a program costs, for example, $25,000 per graduate or $3,000, whether it covers its own costs with its own revenue, and how much subsidy it needs.

Some programs, he acknowledges, will never cover their costs at their scale. For those, VU looks for partners. John Deere, he says, donates close to $1 million of equipment each year for students to work on, equipment VU could never supply on its own. That keeps VU’s John Deere program viable and produces the talent the company needs.

A concerning enrollment trend, Johnson says, “sparks the questions”: whether the program is missing the mark, whether the market has moved on, or whether VU has positioned it poorly through the way it offers courses or its reputation. Each has a different remedy. VU still conducts a formal program review about every five years, but “five years is a long time to look back.”

Annual data of this kind is the groundwork for academic realignment decisions made before a program reaches a crisis.

A Teacher Apprenticeship Built From a Shortage

Asked how VU decides which new programs to build, Johnson describes an entrepreneurial habit: look for needs in the marketplace the institution could fill, then ask why it is not filling them now. In Indiana, he says, the shortage of qualified, credentialed teachers is significant and growing, and “we aren’t gonna get there by continuing just to pump more people through traditional education pipeline models.”

VU’s double-licensure elementary and special education program is an associate-plus-two route to a bachelor’s degree. Johnson points out that it serves a largely regional population because its student-teaching placements are with regional schools. A student 150 miles away in northern Indiana does not want to student-teach in Vincennes. So VU is helping associate degree holders get hired as paraprofessionals in elementary schools, earning money and gaining experience like an apprenticeship, while they complete baccalaureate courses that VU has moved online.

The program is piloting with about half a dozen schools, and Johnson expects to expand it significantly next year. He argues it makes a bachelor’s degree in education “more attainable, more affordable, and more attractive,” and lets people who want to serve the communities they come from stay there.

A Faculty Model Built to Pivot

Johnson describes a two-pronged faculty model. VU has traditional ranked faculty and a tenure program, but with limits. The board suspended tenure for about 10 or 12 years in the early 2000s, he says, after finding the tenure ranks unwieldy; reinstating it was one of his first jobs as provost. The board then required that no more than 50% of faculty in a program, department or school hold tenure or tenure-track positions. Heavy tenure, he says, had “handcuffed” VU whenever enrollments shifted significantly or program areas needed to change.

The second prong serves many of the business and industry courses: full-time, 12-month instructors who are not on the tenure track and teach about 30 to 35 hours a week. Johnson says the combination gives VU the flexibility to respond to changes in enrollment, technology and demographics, and adds that VU’s faculty generally come from the fields they teach.

McNaughton describes an institution he worked with where tenure-track faculty taught the foundational courses while instructors from Silicon Valley taught the advanced ones. Johnson calls it an appropriate model, while noting that industry has maybe had “a little too high expectations for what we can do in an academic program”; experienced instructors, apprenticeships and work-based learning together, he says, help balance that.

Johnson also argues that shared governance is healthy “for the most part” but does not allow an institution to move quickly. The answer, he suggests, may lie in a blend built on trust: faculty and staff who believe the president “will come back and change course” if needed. That kind of trust is central to any shared governance conversation.

What’s Next: Adult Learners, Aviation and a Leaner Campus

VU’s new strategic plan focuses on diversifying its pipeline and reaching more adult learners, a group the podcast examined in its episode on redesigning an institution for adult learners. Aviation is one priority. Johnson says enrollment in VU’s aviation programs, based at its aviation technology center in Indianapolis, has more than doubled. VU has launched an aviation partnership in the Louisville area and is running a fundraising campaign for the capital investment it requires.

In Indianapolis, VU is working with Marian University on a workforce development partnership. As a partner in Associated Builders and Contractors’ apprenticeship program, VU has added a prep academy, a pre-apprenticeship program around Indiana for high school students who want to go into the trades. The trades, Johnson says, are “really hot in Indiana,” especially with the discussion around investment in data centers.

Johnson also says VU probably needs to look at whether its Vincennes and Jasper campuses have a larger footprint than it needs. If students come more episodically rather than for a consistent 12- to 15-week stretch, he asks, does VU need as much classroom and computer lab space? It has already cut back quite a few computer labs because students have their own devices. The aim, in his words, is to make the institution “leaner, meaner, and more responsive.”

For boards, the facilities question follows from the enrollment model: an institution that serves learners episodically may need less space, used differently.

Three Takeaways for University Presidents and Boards

The following recommendations reflect the perspective of Chuck Johnson.

  1. Stay close to the industries you want to serve. Johnson’s first recommendation is to make industry’s voice part of the institution’s planning and discussion. At VU, that means roughly 35 industry advisory councils and a board drawn from the sectors the university supports.
  2. Lean into your strengths. Echoing a point McNaughton made during the conversation, Johnson advises institutions to do what they do well and go out with those strengths. “Don’t try to make yourself what somebody else is if you’ve already got things that you do well,” he says.
  3. Look outside the traditional academic box. Johnson urges presidents and boards not to be afraid to try things outside the traditional academic model, and not to feel they need a degree program for every solution they bring to the workforce. As he said earlier in the conversation, a learner who earns industry certifications and becomes more employable counts as a win at VU, even without a degree.

About Our Guest

Charles R. “Chuck” Johnson, Ph.D., has served as Vincennes University’s 22nd president since 2015. Under his leadership, VU has expanded work-based learning partnerships with employers including Toyota, Amazon, Walmart, Cummins, and others, connecting education directly to career opportunities. He has championed Early College programs, including development of nearly 20 Career and Technical Education Early Colleges, reaching thousands of Indiana students, and advanced technology education through the Center for Applied Robotics and Automation and a statewide network of collaborative robot labs. Johnson has also led initiatives to strengthen student retention, expand tutoring and learning support, build international partnerships, and modernize facilities. Together, these efforts are helping reshape higher education by demonstrating how universities can integrate academic learning, employer partnerships, and flexible pathways to serve students and meet workforce needs. His focus reflects VU’s commitment to accessible education, student success, and economic opportunity within the region and across Indiana.

Connect with Chuck Johnson on LinkedIn→

About the Host

Dr. Drumm McNaughton is the founder, CEO, and Principal Consultant at The Change Leader, Inc. A highly sought-after higher education consultant with 20+ years of experience, Dr. McNaughton works with leadership, management, and boards of both U.S. and international institutions. His expertise spans key areas, including accreditation, governance, strategic planning, presidential onboarding, mergers, acquisitions, and strategic alliances. Dr. McNaughton’s approach combines a holistic methodology with a deep understanding of the contemporary and evolving challenges facing higher education institutions worldwide to ensure his clients succeed in their mission.

Connect with Drumm McNaughton on LinkedIn→

Transcript: Changing Higher Ed podcast 335 – with host Dr. Drumm McNaughton and guest Chuck Johnson


Introduction to Changing Higher Ed®

Welcome to Changing Higher Ed®, a podcast dedicated to helping higher education leaders improve their institutions. With your host, Dr. Drumm McNaughton, CEO of The Change Leader, a consultancy that helps higher ed leaders holistically transform their institutions. Learn more at changinghighered.com. And now, here’s your host, Drumm McNaughton.

 

[00:00:31] Introducing Chuck Johnson

Drumm McNaughton: Thank you, David. My guest today is Dr. Chuck Johnson, 22nd president of Vincennes University. Chuck began at VU as its provost in 2012 and then assumed the presidency in 2015. Under his leadership, VU has expanded workforce-based learning partnerships with employers that include Toyota, Amazon, Walmart, Cummins, and others, connecting education directly to career opportunities.

He’s championed early college programs, including development of nearly 20 career and technical education early colleges, and has reached thousands of Indiana students, including advanced technology education through the Center for Applied Robotics and Automation and a statewide network of collaborative robot labs.

Chuck has led initiatives that strengthen student retention, expanded tutoring and learning support, built international partnerships, and modernized facilities. And he joins me today to talk about Vincennes University and how they’ve partnered with Indiana and industry to become a shining example of the right way to do workforce development.

Chuck, welcome to the program.

Chuck Johnson: Thank you, Drumm. Nice to be here.

Drumm McNaughton: It’s my pleasure. I am looking forward to a really great conversation. You’ve done some amazing things at Vincennes especially around enrollment, the enrollment cliff is impacting, et cetera. Before we get into the conversation today, give us a little bit of your background, if you would. I was fascinated when I heard it last week for the first time.

[00:02:06] From Bowling Green and Purdue to Vincennes

Chuck Johnson: Well, so I have been in higher education now, gosh, in some form or fashion, probably 42, 43 years. I started out in student affairs area and then moved over to the business school at Bowling Green State University and ran their baccalaureate advising and then the graduate programs and master’s programs there.

And then went into the banking industry for a few years in human resources and training and development, and decided I missed higher education, so it was time for me to look to come back. And an opportunity came my way to end up at Purdue University at the Krannert School of Management, where I was the director of the master’s programs, MBA and master’s degree programs.

And then eventually that role expanded, including executive education degree and non-degree programs while I was there. So a great experience being able to work with working adults and professionals, as well as those who were career changers and looking to enhance the next step of their careers.

While I was there, I also had the good fortune of working as a consultant and later a member of the board of advisors for a startup university in Kuwait, the American University of the Middle East. Did that for about four or five years, and that was a wonderful experience to first of all, just learn about different cultures, different expectations for higher education in the world and to be part of a ground-up organization. They were starting from practically nothing. And that was a really helpful experience.

And after that, I ended up at Vincennes University in the role of provost. Did that for about three years, and then our president at the time decided to retire. Had some family issues that caused him to decide to retire a little earlier than expected, and the board appointed me as interim president August of 2015. And then I got the formal title in December of 2015, so almost 11 years now.

Drumm McNaughton: Wow. That’s a neat background. I really enjoy talking with presidents, but especially those who have industry experience. How did that industry experience change your perspective and make you a better president, or did it?

[00:03:58] What Industry Taught a University President

Chuck Johnson: Oh, absolutely. It opened my eyes to how higher education is seen often by folks outside of higher education. That some of the things that we perhaps take as sacrosanct or givens are not assumptions that are in industry, that we need to move faster, we need to be able to be more nimble, and we need more responsive and not rest on the way we’ve always done things. And that experience in industry was really critical to help deepen my understanding of those things.

Drumm McNaughton: Mm-hmm. Yeah, you’re absolutely right on that. Industry does not slow down. They keep moving very quickly, and in industry, it’s generally okay to make mistakes, step back, get them fixed, and learn from your mistakes. That’s a little different in higher ed.

Chuck Johnson: Traditionally it is. Obviously with shared governance, you have a lot of voices at the table, you have a lot of folks that want to have their opinions incorporated into whatever decisions are being made. And that’s a healthy thing, I think, for the most part, but it doesn’t allow you to move quickly.

And so what you need, I think, in higher education is a blend. Right? You wanna make sure you have a lot of voices and a lot of hands involved, but you don’t wanna be held back by that. And so finding a way to strike that happy medium. And I think that maybe is more about building trust with your faculty and staff and having them be able to buy into the mission and what you’re trying to do, and trust that you aren’t gonna take them too far down a bad road, that you will come back and change course if you need to.

Drumm McNaughton: Mm-hmm. We had a great example of that in COVID, where people had to pivot to online immediately within a week to two weeks, and some institutions were able to do it more easily than others.

Chuck Johnson: Yeah, that was a forced conversion. Right? We had little choice to do that. I know everybody struggled with that, our faculty struggled, but I was very proud of how we came through that. And as you, you know, can imagine with some of the courses that we teach that are very hands-on and technical courses, that was a real challenge to go to a completely online version of finishing out a course with six weeks to go.

Fortunately, for a lot of our courses that were using that pedagogical style, they had gotten pretty close to their end outcomes already by the midterm, and so we were able to manage to get to the very end point without having to have too much of a diminishment of the experience for the students.

Drumm McNaughton: That was so critical at that period of time. There weren’t a lot of institutions in the same place. Give us a little background on Vincennes if you would, because as I see Vincennes, and from our conversation, you’re really uniquely positioned to take advantage of some of the current challenges that higher ed’s having.

[00:06:31] Indiana’s Oldest College and Its Junior College Mission

Chuck Johnson: We are a unique institution. I guess kind of unique is redundant. We’re a unique institution. We are the oldest college in Indiana and one of the oldest in the Midwest. We were founded in 1801, before Indiana was a state. When Vincennes was the Indiana territorial capital so all of Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, and part of Minnesota were governed from little Vincennes, Indiana.

And William Henry Harrison, who later became President of the United States, was territorial governor, and he was our founder. So we started there as a frontier university, and then kind of tried to bounce around, find our mission, find our way. And then over about the 60 or 70 years that followed, we emerged as a two-year school, a junior college, in 1889.

So we actually predate Joliet Junior College who’s often cited as the first junior college, by about 12 years. And so we’ve had this unique spot in the higher education landscape since then. And in the 1960s we’re the only junior college in Indiana. We didn’t have a community college system.

And so, we actually started building residence halls to attract students from all over Indiana, the 92 counties, to Vincennes. And so we have a residential campus in Vincennes, primarily a two-year mission and that was kind of a unique mix. And then in the late ’90s, the state of Indiana had a plan to kind of create a statewide community college system with transfer opportunities everywhere.

And right at that point, Vincennes was the only transfer school. The other school in the state was primarily a technical and CTE school, Ivy Tech, and they put us together in a a, a merger. And things got off to a little bit of a rocky start, and then they decided about four or five years later that they had a different idea in mind, and so we got split up.

And Ivy Tech became the Community College of Indiana with a lot of the transfer programs that they didn’t have before. And Vincennes University got to pick up about seven baccalaureate programs that we didn’t have before to allow us to extend our mission. And so again, we still operate primarily as a junior college.

The vast majority of our credentials awarded are AS degrees. But we also have the baccalaureate pathways that are growing, and we have a number of certificate programs that are aligned with industry and with workforce needs. And that’s really been something we’ve leaned in a lot lately.

[00:08:37] The Enrollment Cliff and a Scrappy Institution

Drumm McNaughton: Mm-hmm. Well, that really sets you up very well, and we’ll get into it because with the public perception being what it is, the workforce perspectives, enrollment cliffs. When we talked the other day, you said that enrollment cliffs got everybody under pressure. Instead of the 65% of college seniors going to college university, it’s down to 51. They’re going directly into the workforce or they’re not going to college. But yet you guys have turned the page on that, and you’re actually doing very well.

Chuck Johnson: Well, we’ve found different ways. I talk about our history. We have a history of being a scrappy institution. We find ways to get the job done even if it’s not the way we’ve always done it. And so I think we’ve done that as well in, in the last several years. Yeah, so in Indiana, the high school to college going rate has declined, and the high school cohort’s declining. So you’ve got this double whammy.

To some extent there’s potential that you could offset the population decline by just getting that percentage of students to go on directly to college, but that’s a heavy lift right now given the questions and the concerns around the ROI of college. So we’ve tried to figure out how do we position ourselves with programming that is maybe not leading directly to a baccalaureate degree at 18 with stackable credentials, with workforce-aligned credentials, a lot of work-based learning and apprenticeships. We’re very fortunate to be the first school in the country to work with Amazon on our nationwide apprenticeship in mechatronics and automation.

That has propelled us to lean into that model more and we just recently brought on other partners in that model and we’re making about a $20 million investment into renovating one of our residence halls to support those kinds of programs because we can become a turnkey solution for the employers that have a need for a nationwide workforce development partner. And so that has helped sustain us. While traditional numbers have suffered, those numbers have continued to grow. And we’ve also leaned into things like our aviation technology center in Indianapolis, where our number of our aviation maintenance and airframe and power plant associates has grown by more than double in the last five years.

[00:10:40] Industry Credentials, Not Only Degrees

Drumm McNaughton: Mm-hmm. So take us through the process that you used to get to this point. I would assume it had a lot to do with looking what you were good at, looking what the environment, what it needed, leverage part, you know, take us through that if you would.

Chuck Johnson: So we’ve had a long history of working closely with industry, particularly in Southwest Indiana where we’re based. And that led to us being part of really creative models, sitting down with employers and creating customized solutions. So we were building that capability all along. And then when new opportunities came up to work with companies like Amazon we had some experience in doing that and adjusting what we’re doing.

And the other thing that we did, Drumm, is we didn’t fixate on the academic credentials being the only goal that we were trying to produce. We looked at industry credentials, we looked at certifications that we could help folks acquire that would have value in the marketplace, and we wanted to make them stackable into the next level of education. But if someone came to us and got four industry certifications, they’re more employable, and were able to use that and to advance their careers and their lives, that was seen as a win by us, even if it didn’t show up in our traditional count of degree production or something like that.

So, I think it’s just being open to working with employers, understanding what they need, being willing to go outside the box in terms of the traditional academic program to accomplish it, and then wanting to stay true to, as you say, the things that we’ve done well, which are a lot of it in technology, in healthcare, in automotive, diesel technology, aviation, fields that we have tremendous expertise and have made significant investments in.

Drumm McNaughton: Well, I would have to guess, and it’s a total guess on my part, that this just didn’t drop down, you know, like manna from the heavens. It required a little bit of work or maybe a lot of work on your part, on your team’s part. How did you go about figuring out this is where we wanted to go? Did you reach out to Amazon, say, “Hey, we can do all these things for you”? How’d it work?

Chuck Johnson: Well, so, the Amazon case is a unique one, but you know, we’ve long had a business and industry arm of the organization that has been focused on working directly with employers on specific workforce needs, most of it non-credit. And they’ve been operating for some time and oftentimes they work with us they build out maybe different pathways in areas that we offer academic pathways in. For example, in advanced manufacturing, you know, we work closely with manufacturers in southern Indiana and throughout Indiana. They can do short course training, up-skill training, and things like that, that are patterned on or building on the, the academic programs that we have or the apprenticeship programs that we have. So that’s been in existence.

[00:13:17] “We Deliver Things Overnight”: The Amazon Apprenticeship

Chuck Johnson: Amazon in particular came to us in 2019. We had a logistics training center just outside the Indianapolis Airport in central Indiana. And the person who was leading Amazon’s new mechanization, robotics, and automation group happened to live in central Indiana at the time and was aware of that facility, came out and visited just to see what we were doing. And they were looking for a model to up-skill some of their technical people, the folks that keep those systems running in those fulfillment centers, for their new fulfillment center they were opening in the south side of Indianapolis.

Initially it was just gonna be do some training and we’ll do some episodic things. Then about six weeks later, this was probably May of 2019, they came back to us and said, “No, we think we’d like to launch an apprenticeship program, and we’d like it to have a four-year DOL registered apprenticeship, and you’ll do the training and we’ll align it to some credentials and things and certifications.” And we were like, “Okay, great.” And I’m, you know, thinking we can move pretty quickly, but I’m thinking, “Okay, we don’t have anything set in place here.” I’m looking at maybe early 2020, which I’m thinking is six, seven months. That’s pretty lightning speed for a university. And they said, “You don’t understand. We deliver things overnight. So we’ve got to, we gotta move faster.” So they said, “We’re gonna open a new fulfillment center at the end of September, a little over four months away. We’d like to start the apprenticeship program then.”

Well, we had no apprentices. They had no apprentices. We had no equipment. We didn’t have faculty lined up, and we didn’t have a curriculum, and we didn’t have certifications But in September of 2019, we launched that program with 44 associates, and 43 of them eventually completed the program a couple years later. That program started with this model of servicing Central Indiana, but we asked them to come to our Vincennes campus, the folks that were leading that program, to just talk and see what we can do there.

And that’s where we kind of, put the idea in their heads that, you know, we’ve got this residential campus. We have all the capabilities, the faculty, the equipment, everything else that you might need. We could do this for you at a broader scale. And sure enough, they came back to us in November, December and said, ” We’d like to pilot with you a nationwide apprenticeship model, looking a little bit different, maybe more of an intensive 12-week training program. Do it on your campus. Live in your residence halls, and we’ll get this started.” Well, the plan was, this was, you know, December of 2019, November 2019. So I had gotten a little wiser by then, so I figured it would be early 2020 when we got to this. March of 2020 was the the designated start point.

We we got delayed though by COVID, and that was right when everything was shutting down. But we did actually start it in May of 2020, and since then, we have graduated some 1,200 apprentices from the initial training program from all over North America. And we developed with them the credentialing, the testing protocol for that. We do all the testing on our testing center. We provide all the housing. They have access to meals. They have access to all the other amenities and things that any student would have. And they’re able to do this because we can scale it up on campus and make it a turnkey operation.

[00:16:10] Walmart and the Launch of Workforce U

Chuck Johnson: Well, fortunately that has gone well with Amazon. But we also thought we wanted to see if we could branch it out with other partners, and Walmart came on last fall and piloted a couple programs and have brought that program up to full steam this year. So Amazon and Walmart are our two anchor partners, but we’re looking at growing this going further. And we recently made a big announcement that as part of our focus on workforce development and relationships like this and many others, we just announced rebranding our business and industry area as Workforce U. And we’ve trademarked that and we are using that to help clearly indicate that this is not just traditional college experiences. This is about something that works with you on developing the talent you need.

[00:16:53] How Other Institutions Can Start

Drumm McNaughton: A question pops to mind because to me this is fascinating. You’ve been able to rebrand the institution, you’ve built on your strengths, but what about an institution that doesn’t have the kind of talent that you do? They’re not a community college. How do they do something like this?

Chuck Johnson: Well, I think first and foremost, it’s getting close to the industry sectors that they have, you know, a history with, that they have produced many graduates for and making sure that they are staying close to them and what their needs might be. We have probably 35 industry advisory councils that we use for different programs and things.

They meet regularly to get feedback from our alumni and from our employer partners about what’s working, what’s not, what’s changing, what’s on the horizon and how do we adapt our curriculum or adapt our models to be able to meet their needs. So that’s helpful. Having that kind of feedback loop and connection’s good.

And I think maybe, again, as I said, not being so fixated on baccalaureate degrees is the only way we can add value to the community and to the workforce pipeline or associate degrees for that matter. So I think that it’s looking at where do you have strengths? And, you know, many schools have local partners or regional partners that they work with. Find out more about what they need and what’s changing in their world.

In our case, leaning into automation and robotics and those kinds of technical areas, that’s a sweet spot for us. We feel, again, that’s an area that we can build on, but there are other areas that we’re not as perhaps facile with or capable of that others could fill that gap.

[00:18:25] Industry Advisory Councils

Drumm McNaughton: Yeah. Well, you mentioned something interesting that most institutions don’t do is the advisory councils. If an institution wants to partner with industry, advisory councils are really great way to do it because they’re gonna tell you what they need, and if you’re responsive enough, they’re gonna start bringing their employees to you to get educated.

Am I right?

Chuck Johnson: Oh, absolutely. And we have, you know, programmatic advisory councils. I have advisory councils at my level for various markets that we serve and things. We serve on industry councils at the state level and some at the national level. So we’re very plugged into what’s going on in industry some of which, you know, is just being aware, and some of which is informing the future of what we’re doing.

We may not be doing it today, but we wanna position ourselves in three or four years to be doing something. You know, obviously AI is a huge question mark is how it’s gonna impact all that we do, not just in teaching and instruction, but in terms of industry and how does AI impact things in manufacturing or healthcare or automotive or whatever it might be.

But we’ve gotta be in those conversations as early as possible so that we understand and we can interpret what that means for how we prepare our students.

[00:19:32] Annual Program Metrics and Cost per Graduate

Drumm McNaughton: Mm-hmm. And also too, faculty need to get that input, but at the same time, these, these programs have to stay profitable. And one of the things that, that I liked what you said when we spoke last week was you do annual program audits to manage staffing and cost. Tell me about those.

Chuck Johnson: So we, it’s an annual program metrics report where we look at enrollment, degree production, other credential production, and then the cost of instruction, whether that’s personnel or sometimes capital or equipment. And we just calculate a cost factor. Is it costing us, you know, $25,000 per graduate for this program, or $3,000 per graduate, or is this program covering its own cost with its own revenue, or how much is the subsidy happening?

As you know from higher education, you have some programs that are never gonna be able to cover their costs because the scale just won’t cover the expenses involved in teaching them. So in those cases, we’ve looked for partners, for example, to maybe help cover some of the cost for equipment that needs to be up to date and maintained.

Our John Deere program is much like that, where they donate close to a million dollars of equipment each year for our people to work on. We could never go out and supply that equipment under our own cost. So that helps keep that program viable from the standpoint of producing the talent that John Deere needs, but also giving us a financial model that we’re not underwater you know, a thousand degrees.

Drumm McNaughton: And it certainly locks in that partner too, which is a nice thing.

Chuck Johnson: Absolutely. And then the other thing, of course, is we wanna make sure that we are not being frivolous in our expenditures, that we’re being strategic in what we’re investing in. So if you look at programs and you have a, a trend line with enrollment that is concerning, you have to ask, what’s going on?

It sparks the questions, right? Is this program just not hitting the mark? Is this program no longer you know, appropriate for the market? Has the market moved on from it? Or is this a problem where we’ve not positioned the program well, either because of the way we offer the courses or because of the reputation that we’ve developed in the marketplace?

And all of those have different prescriptive solutions for them. And without looking at those numbers on a regular basis, we’re kind of flying blind. We do, you know, a, a official program review is about every five years or so, but five years is a long time to look back and say, “Oh, we missed the mark four years ago, and we’re missing the mark even further down the road.”

So this just keeps us sharp and gives us attention point kind of data that we can focus on.

[00:21:53] An Apprenticeship Model for Teachers

Drumm McNaughton: How do you bring a new program on? How do you decide what the program needs to be? You know, for example, you mentioned you’ve got a new model for your K-12 partners where you’re doing apprenticeships for teachers. How did you come up with that program and I’m an entrepreneur at heart. What can I

Chuck Johnson: Yeah. I think it is being a little entrepreneurial. I think it’s looking at where there are needs in the marketplace that you have the ability to perhaps fill and then looking at why you’re not filling it now, right? So I think in our case, it’s recognizing that in Indiana, as a lot of places, the dearth of qualified teachers, credentialed teachers, is significant and growing.

We aren’t gonna get there by continuing just to pump more people through traditional education pipeline models. So how can we get there? At the same time, we have a lot of K-12 partners that we work with across the state. Their needs are great. We have curriculum handshakes and pathways that they’re doing in high school that lead to our credentials.

We also know that we have, you know, our education programs in particular, our double licensure elementary and special ed program, has a very regional population that we serve because our contacts are with regional schools, our placements are with regional schools. If someone’s in northern Indiana, 150 miles away from Vincennes, they don’t wanna do their student teaching in Vincennes. They wanna do their student teaching where they live back home, and they can maybe save money from having to pay to live in an apartment or on campus.

What if we took our AS programs, ’cause ours is an AS+2 to a BS program. What if we took those AS credentialed candidates from VU or elsewhere and let them get hired by or put them up for opportunities to be hired as paraprofessionals in those elementary schools where they could be teacher’s aides or classroom assistants or whatever it might be, earn some money, deepen their experience in the field like an apprenticeship, and get their baccalaureate program courses done online.

And so we’ve moved all of our baccalaureate program courses online. So we’ve facilitated the small. We’re piloting with about a half dozen schools right now. I think we’re gonna expand it next year to significantly, and I see this as a model that makes a bachelor’s degree in education, particularly those two fields, more attainable, more affordable, and more attractive because, again, I don’t wanna generalize, people in, in education generally wanna serve the communities they come out of. And so this gives them an opportunity to stay local and be part of that community that they maybe have a, a great attachment to.

Drumm McNaughton: This to me is a great example of taking or knowing what you’re good at, what you can do, what you can expand, understanding what the market needs, and being able to work with that industry, that marketplace, to give them something that’s gonna be meaningful for them. Kudos to you guys there at Vincennes. I am impressed.

Chuck Johnson: Our, our folks are really good, and again, I think it has a lot to do with the fact that our faculty generally come from the fields that they’re teaching in, so they’re already fully aware of what some of those needs are, but also because we try to stay very close to our industry partners.

[00:24:49] A Two-Pronged Faculty Model and Limits on Tenure

Drumm McNaughton: Mm-hmm. Speaking of faculty, you use a little different model than most, quote, “traditional universities.” Please tell me about it.

Chuck Johnson: We, we do have traditional faculty with rank and we have a tenure program. Our board suspended tenure for about ten or twelve years in the early two thousands after they found that we were just unwieldy in our tenure ranks, and so they suspended tenure. And actually, one of my first jobs coming in as provost was the reinstatement of tenure.

And the board put very strict requirements on tenure and tenure track lines. They said no more than fifty percent of faculty could be at a tenure or tenure track position at any one time at a program or department level or school level. And the reason for that was it just handcuffed us with any kind of pivoting we needed to do if program enrollments shifted significantly or if program areas needed to be reappropriated or whatever it might be.

So this limitation in the traditional faculty ranks has given us a lot more flexibility that we’re not so heavily tenured that we can’t be nimble to adjust for changes in enrollments and changes in technology and demographics. And then for a lot of our business and industry courses, we actually hire people as full-time instructors, not tenured track or tenured faculty.

They’re paid to be twelve-month instructors and they teach maybe thirty or thirty-five hours a week in these courses where they’re focused on industry. So it’s a kind of a two prong faculty model. One is traditional academic program with very strong limits on tenure and tenure track, and the other one is a traditional, just full-time instructional model, trainer model. And that has given us a lot of flexibility and nimbleness with respect to how we can respond.

Drumm McNaughton: And that is so critical when you’re going after new ideas, new programs. You need to be able to do that. One indus- one institution that I worked with a while back, they had their tenure track folks working on the fundamental courses, the basics, and they had the adjuncts or the, the instructors who were coming directly out of Silicon Valley with the latest and greatest.

They were teaching the higher level courses, so when their graduates graduated or their students graduated, they knew the latest and greatest was going on in the valley.

Chuck Johnson: No, I think it’s exactly an appropriate model. We want folks to have skills that are immediately applicable. I mean, I understand and I don’t think anyone should expect someone coming directly out of college is 100% prepared for every job that they’re qualified for, right? I think that sometimes industry has maybe had a little too high expectations for what we can do in an academic program.

But that marrying of the people who have that experience in the instructional environment and the strong connections, as well as what we try to do with apprenticeships and work-based learning programs, does kind of help balance that out a bit so that graduates are coming out with a better skill set and a better awareness of what they’re getting themselves into.

[00:27:36] A Board That Brings Industry to the Table

Drumm McNaughton: Yeah. And to be able to make this whole thing function, you’ve got to have an incredible board.

Chuck Johnson: Oh, absolutely. My board is amazing. They represent so many different of the sectors that we support: healthcare, advanced manufacturing, energy agriculture. They are folks that very much understand the mission of the institution, but they also bring to the table ideas. Again, on top of everything else, that, that’s one of my advisory councils right there. They’re folks that are bringing connections and keeping us abreast of what’s happening in their industries as well as in their communities.

So they’ve been tremendous, and I’ve been very blessed that they are very supportive of me as president. They’re very supportive of the institution, but they don’t come in with their own agendas. They don’t come in with you know, trying to run the institution. They come in trying to help the institution be its best and fulfill their fiduciary and leadership responsibilities.

Drumm McNaughton: What comes to mind is NIFO, “nose in, fingers out.”

Chuck Johnson: Very good. Very good. I’ve not heard that. That’s good. That’s good.

[00:28:34] Results: Enrollment, Aviation and Early College

Drumm McNaughton: Tell me about the results that you’ve had, because I know they’ve been superb, superb. You know, enrollment, you talked about one earlier, filling capacity for residence halls, getting them updated. That, that’s big.

Chuck Johnson: It is big. It’s huge, and, you know, I think we’re undertaking several initiatives at once. First of all, our enrollment on our Vincennes campus has been pretty static. In the last three or four years it’s been about 2,300 to 2,400 students, but our system-wide headcount number has been about 20,000 last fall.

And that’s because of all the different pathways that we have, and that doesn’t include these Amazon, Walmart, and other numbers. Those are separate numbers, so because they don’t show up in our traditional enrollment numbers, which is something we’re also looking at. How do we make sure that we are accounting for those numbers?

Because they’re making a contribution to our communities and our state. They may not show up in what the state counts as a degree completion or something, but it still counts toward the impact we’re having. So we’re working on that. That’s part of our strategic plan. But I mentioned our aviation programs more than doubled enrollment in the last four years.

We’re investing in expanding partnerships in key locations around the state of Indiana. We do a lot with early college programs around the state in the career and technical pathways, where they’re getting practical coursework and experience that aligns to workforce needs in those communities that also stack into a next-level credential to Vincennes University.

And so I think we’ve looked at a portfolio, if you will that it can’t all be … I would love the Vincennes campus to have everything and everyone, but that’s not practical in this environment. We can’t wait for people to come to us and so we are doing all we can to reach out and be, you know, I guess a viable partner in different locations around the state.

[00:30:17] Working With Indiana Economic Development

Drumm McNaughton: You’ve also partnered with the Indiana Economic Development folks, and that has made a good impact on what you’re doing. Am I right?

Chuck Johnson: They’re very supportive of what we need. Of course their focus on workforce is critical and we get involved in a lot of conversations where they’re trying to bring in new industry partners and that is helpful to have us at the table early on, both to give us the awareness of what might be coming down the pike, and also to help the potential employers to understand what capabilities they have here in the city of Indiana, VU, Ivy Tech, other institutions that are there to work with them.

And so, you know, having a group like IEDC is very helpful to be kind of the point of the spear on changing industry sectors and what we’re trying to bring to Indiana.

[00:31:02] A Junior College That Offers Baccalaureate Degrees

Drumm McNaughton: And I just wanna reiterate for the listeners that yours is not a traditional institution. You came from the community college, the junior college ranks, so you think this way. So instead of being a traditional university offering workforce development, you really are a junior college workforce development that offers baccalaureate degrees. It’s a little bit of a difference especially from a mentality perspective.

Chuck Johnson: It is. It is. And I think one of the challenges I think we’ve had, Drumm, has been reminding ourselves that we have more than associate degrees, ’cause for many years, that was the the be-all, end-all of our mission. And we’ve built out a lot more certificates in the last few years, but we’re also wanting to really use our baccalaureate programs where they make sense to, to kind of find new industry partners and help meet new needs.

So one of the areas, you know, that we have is in our technology baccalaureate program, and we are converting our online courses to eight-week courses to make it easier for adult learners to get through sequences of courses and things. We have an RN to BSN and an LPN to BSN pathway that is.

The RN to BSN pathway is all online for working adults. The LPN to BSN pathway is also for working adults. Some of it is not online at this point because of some of the clinical work that still needs to be done, but it it’s an example of what we’re doing. This BSN education model that we have is working that way. We’ve got a bachelor’s degree in homeland security, and a lot of our graduates in that program come out of our military education sites.

Drumm McNaughton: This is fabulous. You guys are just doing such a great example. I’m gonna reference you in future podcasts because I really like what I’m hearing, so thank you for that permission. I’m assuming I have it.

Chuck Johnson: Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. I’m always proud and happy to brag on the work of our people.

[00:32:44] Three Takeaways for Presidents and Boards

Drumm McNaughton: I appreciate it. As we always do to wrap up, two questions. First one, three takeaways for your fellow presidents and boards. What do they need to do to build a program like this?

Chuck Johnson: I think first is make sure that they’re staying close to the industry that they wanna serve and making sure they have the, their voice involved in their planning and discussion. The second I would say is, as you’ve pointed out in your comments, lean into your strengths. Do what you do well and go out with those, and don’t try to make yourself what somebody else is if you’ve already got things that you do well.

And the third, I think, is don’t be afraid to try things that are outside the traditional academic box, and don’t feel like you have to have a degree program for every single solution that you’re bringing to the workforce.

[00:33:27] What’s Next for Vincennes University

Drumm McNaughton: Excellent takeaways. What’s next for you? What’s next for Vincennes?

Chuck Johnson: Well, we’ve launched our new strategic plan and our focus is diversifying our pipeline of students trying to reach more adult learners. We’ve talked about some of the baccalaureate programs being part of that. We are looking at expanding our aviation programs.

We’re in Indianapolis now. We’ve launched a partnership in the Louisville area with that program and are in a fundraising campaign to get that capital investment made, working closely with partners in industry there. We’re working in Indianapolis, Indiana, with Marian University on a workforce development partnership and expanding our work in the trades.

We are a partner of Associated Builders and Contractors for their apprenticeship program, and we’ve recently expanded that partnership to include a prep academy, a pre-apprenticeship program around the state of Indiana for high school students wanting to go in the trades. And the trades right now are really hot in Indiana, especially with a lot of discussion around the investment needed for data centers and things where electricians and general construction will be critical.

So we’re continuing to evolve the way we do things. We’re continuing to build on the success we’ve had. And of course we just made a commitment to about a $20 million renovation of a major residence hall to make it more adult learner friendly for the kind of programs that we’re talking about.

And then I think the final thing is right-sizing some of our facilities. We’ve got a great campus in Vincennes and in Jasper. But we probably need to take a look at do we have a larger footprint than we need for the kind of learning that’s gonna be taking place in the next five or 10 years?

And where our students may be here often, but maybe less of a consistent 12, 15-week stretch, it may be more episodic. And do we need as much classroom space? Do we need as much computer lab space? We’ve already cut back quite a few computer labs because we just don’t have the need for them.

Students have their own devices and things. So looking at how we make the institution leaner, meaner, and more responsive.

Drumm McNaughton: Wow. I’d love to be fly on the wall or even a board member to watch all this kind of stuff. This is just great.

Chuck, thank you so much for being on the program. I enjoy doing podcasts. This one’s special for me, so thank you.

Chuck Johnson: Thank you, Drumm. I appreciate that very much. It’s been my pleasure.

Drumm McNaughton: Thanks for listening today, and a special thank you to my guest, Chuck Johnson. Chuck, I thoroughly enjoyed our conversation. Thanks for spending some time with me, and all the best to what you’re doing for the folks in Indiana. You’re doing a great job.

To my listeners, thanks again for tuning in. See you next week.

Listen to Changing Higher Ed® Podcast on your favorite subscription service:

Listen to the Changing Higher Ed® podcast on YouTube Music  Listen to Changing Higher Ed Podcast on Apple Podcast  Changing Higher Ed Podcast on Amazon Music    Changing Higher Ed podcast RSS Feed

Share This Post
Recent Posts and Podcasts:

Subscribe to The Change Leader

Get the latest higher ed news and expert insights from our articles, podcasts and newsletters.