Table of Contents
Why Professional Presidential Onboarding is a Necessity
The tenure of university and college presidents has dropped precipitately over the past 15 years. In the not-so-distant past, it wasn’t unusual for a president to be with one institution for 10 to 20 years.
Not anymore!
In 2006, the American Council on Education reported that the average presidential tenure was 8.5 years. Five years later, in 2011, it had dropped to 7 years; in 2017, it was 6.5 years. And in 2022, it was down to 5.9 years. Post-COVID, we are seeing more presidents leave between 3 and 5 years. And that doesn’t take into account those who leave within a year because they weren’t a good fit for the institution.
The costs of presidential turnover at higher education institutions are substantial. From a financial perspective, search firms charge over $100,000 in fees (and, in some cases, well over $250,000), and departing presidents often have substantial separation compensation in their contracts that can cost an institution more than $1 million.
More important is the cost of the turmoil that premature presidential turnover costs colleges and universities in lost opportunities, rudderless leadership, and reputational damage (not to mention the additional search fees – the previous 1-year guarantee by search firms is going the way of the dinosaur).
It is very rare for a newly hired president, especially a first-time president, to be familiar with the job’s internal and external requirements. Higher education institutions cannot afford to lose presidents early in their tenure financially, organizationally, and reputationally.
Now more than ever, governing boards must ensure newly appointed presidents undergo a carefully planned strategic onboarding process that continues through the first year of their tenure. This foundational step paves the way for building longer-term, successful presidencies.
The health and sustainability of our nation’s colleges and universities require nothing less.
Benefits of Presidential Onboarding
Good presidential onboarding practices enable a higher education institution to:
Enable the new president to understand his/her new institution’s mission, culture, and stakeholders
Facilitate building relationships with the board and other key stakeholders required for long-term success
Help the new president build their “first 100-days” agenda based on what is actually happening at the institution
Assist the new president in developing the expertise and knowledge in areas less familiar to them
Provide the board and new president training on the board and president roles and responsibilities in good governance
Enable new presidents to build rapport with institutional stakeholders by knowing issues before starting the “listening tour”
Help the new president understand the strengths and and opportunities at his/her new institution
Provide the structure and process to ensure the new president is successful in the long-term
Circumstances When Presidential Onboarding is Mandatory
While a well-structured onboarding process is important for all presidents, it is absolutely critical in certain instances.
These circumstances can range from a “vote of no-confidence” of the former president to succeeding a long-tenured and highly respected president. Specific examples include:
LEADERSHIP TURNOVER
The last president left under a cloud and stakeholders do not trust leadership
LONG TENURED INCUMBENT
The previous president was in the position more than 10 years
(LACK OF) TURNOVER
There is a new president but the remaining cabinet is resistant to change
(LACK OF) SHARED VISION
Stakeholders are at odds with the institution's vision and mission
FIRST TIME PRESIDENTS
The role of the president is both internal and external facing, and most are experienced in only one or the other
BOARD OVERSIGHT
The accountability and oversight functions of the board need refreshing
BUILDING STAKEHOLDER TRUST
A new president's success starts and ends with relationships; trust-building begins with successful listening tours
SKILL BUILDING
First-time presidents have skill gaps and often need a crash course on board relations, external roles, and/or academic culture
DEFINING BOARD/ PRESIDENTIAL ROLES
The board and new president need to define their respective roles and responsibilities in governance and management
Best Practices for Successful Higher Education Presidential Onboarding
There are a number of higher education presidential transition and onboarding best practices that institutions must embrace to ensure newly hired presidents are successful and stay at the institution long-term. These include:
Higher Education Presidential Onboarding and Transition Best Practices Include:
Conduct a third-party confidential interviews with key stakeholders so the new president understands the institution’s aspirations and challenges
Create a transition team to assist the new president with communications and hold a series of workshops to build rapport and support for the 100-day plan
Set up the “listening tour” with key stakeholders to begin the relationship-building process
Develop and execute a plan that enables the new president to understand and lead the institution
Hold a retreat after the onboarding process to set institutional goals, objectives and priorities with the board, new president, and cabinet
Create a 1-year plan to enable the new president to sustain momentum of the 100-day plan for the full year
Create a strong communication plan to keep the campus engaged throughout the transition
Understanding the hot-spot areas from the previous administration that need special attention
Assess the strengths and areas of improvement for the new president provide coaching if required
Assist developing the presidential evaluation required by accreditors and by good governance practices
How We Help Our Clients
Dr. Drumm McNaughton, Dr. William “Brit” Kirwan, and our higher education consulting team provide presidential transition and onboarding services that can help guide you and your new president through the Higher Ed presidential transition process.
We’ve been there before – we have guided multiple institutions through the onboarding process and have even gone through the process ourselves! We know how to ensure the transition is smooth, that your new president gets the detailed information that they need to be successful, and that they can hit the job running.
Our consultants have helped higher education institutions not only get their new president up to speed, but help them to build their 100-day plan and create strategic plans that ensure they stay in good standing going forward with the multiple stakeholders your institution has, both internal and external to your university or college.
At The Change Leader, we provide unparalleled expertise in presidential onboarding for higher education institutions. Our approach is rooted in decades of experience and a deep understanding of the unique challenges facing university and college leadership.
Our Unique Approach to Presidential Onboarding
We understand that successful presidential onboarding goes beyond standard best practices. Our tailored approach is designed to resonate deeply with your institution’s mission, vision, and values, ensuring a seamless integration of new leadership with your unique institutional culture.
Mission-Centric Alignment: We begin by immersing ourselves in your institution’s core purpose. Our team conducts in-depth analyses of your mission statement, strategic plan, and institutional history to ensure that the onboarding process reinforces and advances your fundamental goals.
Values-Driven Leadership Integration: Recognizing that institutional values are the bedrock of campus culture, we develop customized strategies to help new presidents embody and champion these values from day one. This approach fosters authentic leadership and builds trust across all stakeholder groups.
Vision Actualization Framework: We create a tailored roadmap that bridges the gap between your institution’s long-term vision and the immediate priorities facing the new president. This framework allows for quick wins that build momentum while keeping sight of transformational goals.
Adaptive Stakeholder Synergy: Our unique methodology goes beyond traditional stakeholder engagement. We facilitate collaborative workshops that bring together diverse campus voices – from students to trustees – to co-create initiatives that support the new president’s success while honoring the institution’s collaborative spirit.
Cultural Continuity and Innovation Balance: We help new presidents navigate the delicate balance between honoring institutional traditions and driving necessary innovations. Our approach ensures respect for your institution’s legacy while positioning the new leadership to address future challenges effectively.
Ethical Leadership Empowerment: With the volatile social and political environment of increased scrutiny on higher education, we place special emphasis on equipping new presidents with the tools to lead with transparency, integrity, and a strong ethical compass aligned with your institution’s values and public mission.
Sustainability and Social Impact Integration: For institutions with a strong focus on sustainability and social responsibility, we develop strategies that help new presidents embed these principles into their leadership approach from the outset, ensuring alignment with institutional commitments to societal impact.
This tailored, mission-aligned approach ensures that presidential onboarding is not just a transition of leadership but a holistic, transformative process that reinforces your institution’s unique identity and propels it toward its aspirational goals.
Our Presidential Onboarding Experts
Led by Dr. Drumm McNaughton and Dr. William “Brit” Kirwan, our team brings unique expertise to presidential onboarding:
Dr. Drumm McNaughton: With over 30 years of experience in higher education consulting, Dr. McNaughton has guided numerous institutions through successful presidential transitions. His background in strategic planning, organizational development, and change management provides a holistic perspective on leadership effectiveness.

Dr. William “Brit” Kirwan: As a former university system chancellor and president, Dr. Kirwan brings firsthand experience in higher education leadership. His insights into governance, academic affairs, and stakeholder management are invaluable in preparing new presidents for the complexities of their roles.
Our team’s combined experience covers a wide range of institution types, from small liberal arts colleges to large public university systems, ensuring that we will address the specific needs of your institution.
By choosing The Change Leader for your presidential onboarding and transition, you’re not just getting a service – you’re gaining a partner committed to the long-term success of your new president and your institution.
FAQ- Higher Education Presidential Onboarding Frequently Asked Questions
Presidential Onboarding Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Table of Contents
Most frequent questions about higher education presidential onboarding consulting services
Why do higher education institutions need presidential onboarding services?
Higher education institutions are complex, with unique cultures, governance structures, and stakeholder expectations that vary significantly from one campus to another. Without proper onboarding, even experienced presidents may face challenges in navigating these complexities effectively.
Our presidential onboarding process starts with confidential interviews with key stakeholders—faculty, staff, students, trustees, and donors—to gain a deep understanding of the university’s strengths and areas for improvement. This helps the new president understand institutional culture and key priorities, ensuring they make informed decisions from day one.
Leadership coaching and governance training are crucial components of our services, providing the president with the tools needed to navigate board relationships, manage diverse campus constituencies, and drive strategic initiatives. Additionally, operational assessments and strategic planning help align the president’s vision with institutional goals.
Higher education institutions need these onboarding services to ensure smooth transitions, prevent missteps, and establish a foundation of trust with the campus community. The Change Leader’s comprehensive approach helps new presidents build relationships, create alignment with key stakeholders, and lead the university confidently into its next chapter.
What do presidential onboarding services look like?
At The Change Leader, presidential onboarding services begin with confidential interviews with key stakeholders, such as faculty, staff, students, trustees, and donors. These interviews help the new president gain a comprehensive understanding of the university’s strengths and areas for improvement, allowing them to gauge institutional culture and identify key opportunities early in their tenure.
This first step is critical to tailoring a strategic approach that aligns the president’s vision with the institution’s unique context. In addition to stakeholder insights, The Change Leader provides leadership coaching to guide the president through complex decision-making, relationship-building, and effective change leadership. Our governance training fosters strong collaboration between the president and the board of trustees, ensuring everyone is aligned on priorities and institutional goals.
The Change Leader also conducts operational assessments to evaluate institutional performance and offers strategic planning services to refine the university’s direction. We help build a cohesive executive team through alignment exercises and offer communication strategies that foster transparency and trust across the campus.
By integrating these services, The Change Leader ensures a smooth transition and sets the stage for the new president’s long-term success. Whether the president is new or experienced, our tailored onboarding services provide critical support to navigate their leadership journey effectively.
Are onboarding services required for all incoming presidents? What about those who are experienced presidents?
Whereas onboarding services are not strictly required for all incoming university presidents, especially those who have been presidents at another university, they are highly beneficial. Each higher education institution has its own unique culture, challenges, and stakeholder dynamics, and onboarding services help new leaders acclimate to these specific contexts. Experienced presidents may be skilled in leadership, but a new campus brings different governance structures, political landscapes, and community expectations.
As the saying goes, when you’ve seen one university, you’ve seen one university!
Onboarding provides valuable support by offering insights into institutional history, current strategic goals, and internal relationships, helping presidents tailor their leadership to the new environment. Even seasoned leaders can benefit from stakeholder interviews to understand campus culture and address concerns early in their tenure.
Additionally, onboarding services can foster alignment between the president, the board, and other key stakeholders, ensuring smoother transitions. These services help presidents—whether new or experienced—gain the insight needed to lead effectively from day one, and to develop their own agenda that should lead to a shared vision across the campus.
What services does The Change Leader provide for presidential onboarding and transitions?
The Change Leader provides a number of critical services that support successful presidential onboarding and transitions. These include conducting interviews with key stakeholders—such as faculty, staff, students, trustees, and donors—to gain insights into the current culture and strategic planning to help align the new president’s vision with institutional priorities. This operational assessment helps the new president pinpoint institutional strengths and weaknesses and, when paired with change management services, help to guide the transition and reduce disruption.
These efforts ensure that the new president can build a strong foundation of relationships, especially during the listening tour, and make informed decisions from the start of their tenure.
The Change Leader also offers leadership coaching to prepare the president for the complexities of the role, especially when they are new to the role; governance training to facilitate effective collaboration with the board; and guidance in shaping communication strategies that foster trust across campus.
What's the difference between traditional presidential onboarding and strategic presidential onboarding with a consultant (like The Change Leader)?
A traditional presidential onboarding in higher education typically involves a series of introductions to key stakeholders, campus tours, and internal briefings, while a strategic presidential onboarding with a consulting firm takes a more structured and data-driven approach, utilizing external expertise to deeply analyze the institution’s needs, identify critical challenges, and develop a tailored plan to quickly integrate the new president and achieve strategic goals, often including in-depth stakeholder interviews, leadership development, and ongoing performance monitoring.
| Aspect | Traditional Onboarding | The Change Leader’s Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Analysis Depth | Basic campus tours and introductory meetings with key stakeholders | Comprehensive institutional assessment, including culture diagnostics, financial analysis, and stakeholder relationship mapping |
| Strategic Planning→ | Generic onboarding checklists and standard procedures | Customized 90-day and 12-month action plans aligned with your leadership style and institutional needs |
| Stakeholder Engagement | Surface-level introductions to campus leaders | In-depth stakeholder interviews, relationship-building strategies, and coalition development |
| Performance Monitoring | Limited or no formal progress tracking | Regular check-ins, progress assessments, and strategy adjustments based on real-time feedback |
| Risk Management→ | Reactive approach to challenges as they arise | Proactive identification of potential challenges and strategic opportunities |
| Success Metrics | Informal or undefined success measures | Clear KPIs and milestones for measuring presidential integration and impact that can include long-term presidential evaluations |